Thanks to Chasityxo and this entry, my friend and I will be attempting to make peanutbutter cookies today using her recipe on the bottom of the entry. My friend was coming over today anyway, and when I mentioned the recipe, she said we should try making it! I'll post about the results sometime today or tomorrow, maybe with some pictures.
We did decide that if the cookies end up not coming out so good, we'll just buy some Chips Ahoy peanut butter cookies and pig out on those, haha.
Thanks again for the idea, chasity!